Should I Drop Full Coverage? Calculator

Paying a lot to insure an older car? Compare what full coverage costs you each year with the most it could ever pay out. Then see if liability only makes more sense.

← All free insurance calculators

Compare what full coverage costs you with what it could ever pay out on your car.

How to use this calculator

  1. Enter what your car is worth today. Kelley Blue Book or Edmunds can give you a quick value
  2. Enter how much more you pay each year for collision and comprehensive
  3. Add your collision deductible and say if you still have a loan or lease

How the Full Coverage Calculator Works

Full coverage can never pay more than your car’s value minus your deductible. The calculator shows that maximum payout and compares it with your yearly cost for collision and comprehensive.

A popular rule of thumb says that once full coverage costs 10% or more of the car’s value each year, it may be time to drop it, as long as you could afford to repair or replace the car yourself. If you have a loan or lease, your lender will usually require full coverage.

Frequently asked questions

When should I drop full coverage?

Many drivers consider it when the car is paid off, its value is low and the yearly cost of collision and comprehensive is 10% or more of that value.

What do I lose if I drop full coverage?

Liability only pays for damage and injuries you cause to others. It will not pay to fix or replace your own car after a crash, theft, hail or flood.

Can I keep comprehensive and drop collision?

Often yes. Comprehensive is usually cheap and covers theft, hail and falling objects, so some drivers keep it and drop only collision.

Learn more

Want the full picture? Read our article Full Coverage vs Liability: 3 Smart Ways to Pay Less. You can also try our other free insurance calculators.

Disclaimer: This calculator gives an estimate for general information only. It is not insurance, financial or legal advice. Your real price and coverage depend on your insurer, your state and your personal details. See our Editorial Policy to learn how we research and check our content.

Scroll to Top